Enviro groups: No dredging!

 

http://www.nj.com/news/jjournal/index.ssf?/base/news-2/1104935215221550.xml

 

Vow to sue to prevent disturbing dioxin site under bay, Kill Van Kull

Wednesday, January 05, 2005

By The Associated Press

Several environmental groups charged yesterday that plans to dredge New York Harbor and Newark Bay to allow passage of large ships do not include adequate safeguards for an underwater hazardous waste site.

Any dredging near the Diamond Alkali Superfund site - which includes Newark Bay and portions of the Kill Van Kull off Bayonne - could cause dioxin and other dangerous chemicals to seep into local waterways, said the groups, comprised of the Natural Resources Defense Council, New York/New Jersey Baykeeper and GreenFaith.

The dioxin is left over from Agent Orange produced at a nearby plant during the Vietnam War, the groups said.

The groups said they have filed a notice of intent to sue the Army Corps of Engineers and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey to force the agencies to develop a safe plan for removing the contaminated material at the Superfund site before any dredging is done.

"It's like dropping depth charges into one of the biggest toxic waste dumps on the East Coast with no thought at all about the consequences," said NRDC attorney Brad Sewell.

"This has the potential to be a win-win situation. Hazardous material must eventually be removed from the bay anyhow. But without safeguards they are going to wind up spreading toxic contamination into important recreational and commercial waterways."

Army Corps of Engineers spokesman Peter Shugert said the agency received a notice of intent to sue and was reviewing it. Shugert said the Corps has been involved in major navigation programs since the late 1980s, adheres to "the most stringent testing standards" and uses advanced technology.

"We have and continue to perform extensive testing on all our dredged material to ensure environmental compliance," Shugert said.

Port Authority officials declined to comment.

The multibillion-dollar dredging project is to deepen the shipping channels around New York City and New Jersey to 50 feet. The depth will accommodate the larger ships being built today.

The harbor region is essentially an estuary with a natural depth of 18 feet to 19 feet, and the Port Authority and federal government have already spent $1.2 billion since 1997 on a series of dredging projects deepening channels to up to 45 feet.

From 1951 to 1969, the Diamond Alkali Company owned and operated a pesticides manufacturing plant in Newark.

According to the environmental groups, Newark Bay is one of the world's worst dioxin-contaminated sites.

The state Department of Environmental Protection has banned crabbing in and around Newark Bay and restricts consumption of many types of fish in the area, the groups noted.